December 2, 2023
Scottish Cozy Mysteries

Scottish Cozy Mysteries

The unmistakable allure of the Highlands

Scottish cozy mysteries offer a unique blend of charm, wit, and suspense, set against the backdrop of rolling hills and quaint villages. This genre, while often overlooked, has produced some of the most engaging and delightful mysteries in both literature and screen adaptations.


One prime example is M.C. Beaton’s beloved Hamish Macbeth series. Set in the fictional village of Lochdubh, these books introduce us to the titular character, a clever, unambitious police constable who solves crimes with a mix of intuition and local knowledge. The series’ charm lies in the idyllic Scottish settings and the eccentric, often humorous characters that populate the village. The television adaptation, starring Robert Carlyle, brings the picturesque landscapes and quirky personalities of Lochdubh to life.

Ann Cleeves’ Shetland series, another gem, takes readers to the remote Shetland Islands. Detective Jimmy Perez, a thoughtful and methodical protagonist, navigates the close-knit communities and rugged terrain to uncover secrets and solve murders. The Shetland TV series captures the stark beauty of the islands, creating a moody and atmospheric setting that complements the complex plots.

Alexander McCall Smith’s 44 Scotland Street series, though not strictly a mystery series, deserves mention for its whimsical and lighthearted exploration of Edinburgh’s New Town. The series offers a tapestry of intersecting lives, with mysteries that are more about the quirks and foibles of everyday life than about crime. The charm of these stories lies in the richly drawn characters and the affectionate portrayal of Edinburgh.

Moving to a more traditional cozy mystery format, the Dandy Gilver series by Catriona McPherson is set in the 1920s and 1930s. Dandy Gilver, an aristocratic sleuth, navigates the social circles of Scotland with wit and a keen eye for detail. The series is known for its humorous tone, engaging puzzles, and vivid depiction of post-World War I Scotland.

The Isabel Dalhousie series by Alexander McCall Smith, set in Edinburgh, features a philosopher detective who delves into mysteries that often explore moral and ethical dilemmas. The series stands out for its focus on character development and philosophical musings, set against the charming backdrop of Scotland’s capital.

The Highlands provide the setting for Molly MacRae’s Plaid and Plagiarism, the first in the Highland Bookshop Mystery series. The story revolves around four women who move to Scotland to run a bookshop and find themselves entangled in murder. The series combines the love of books with the allure of a Scottish village, creating a cozy, bookish atmosphere.

In terms of screen adaptations, “Monarch of the Glen” is worth mentioning, although it leans more towards drama than mystery. Set in the fictional Highland estate of Glenbogle, the series offers a light-hearted look at Scottish rural life, replete with charming landscapes and engaging, if not mysterious, storylines.

These Scottish cozy mysteries offer a delightful escape, weaving together the beauty of Scotland with intriguing plots and memorable characters. The genre stands as a testament to the enduring appeal of mysteries that prioritize character and setting over grisly details, proving that sometimes, a little coziness is just what the detective ordered.

More Cozy Mystery Features