November 5, 2023
Suspense and Pacing

Suspense and Pacing

How to Balance Suspense and Pacing in Mystery Writing

Suspense and pacing in mystery writing are like a couple of old-school detectives working a case; they must be in sync or the plot flops harder than a pair of loafers on a beat cop. The maestros of mystery have this balancing act down to an art. For scribes looking to pull readers to the edge of their seats and keep them there without causing a leg cramp, it’s time to talk turkey about the mechanics of this particular beast.


First, let’s gab about suspense. Suspense isn’t just the terror of a creaking floorboard or the classic ‘whodunit’ conundrum; it’s the delicate dance of revealing and concealing information. It’s not the murder that gets the heart racing; it’s the why, the who, and the when-the-heck-are-they-going-to-get-caught. Suspense is the bread that makes the reader’s imagination sandwich hearty. Without it, the story’s as dry as a prohibition-era speakeasy.

Then there’s pacing. Pacing doesn’t just mean how fast the action moves. It’s the rhythm of the story, the beat that dictates the dance of the plot. If the tempo’s too fast, the reader can’t catch a breath. Too slow, and they’re snoring with the book for a pillow. A mystery is like jazz; the beauty’s in the rise and fall, the crescendo and the diminuendo, the unexpected twists in the melody that keep the audience hooked.

So, how does a writer juggle suspense and pacing without dropping the ball? Think of the story as a series of scenes. Each scene is a step in the dance. The key to a good jig is variety. Fast steps mixed with slow, deliberate moves. A chase here, a contemplative moment there. It keeps the toes tapping and the grey cells turning.

For the suspension of breaths, the withholding of information is a prized tool in the writer’s belt. But beware the edge of the knife; too much secrecy and the reader’s left stumbling in the dark. Too little, and there’s no mystery to solve. It’s about slipping just enough clues to keep the audience guessing. Dangle a carrot, then pull it away just before the bite.

Let’s not forget characters. Characters are the lifeblood of a mystery. They’re the vessels through which the suspense flows. Every character has a secret, a ticking time bomb of revelation. The key is timing; let the bomb tick for too long, and the anticipation fizzles out. Detonate too early, and the bang’s more of a whimper. It’s about reading the room, knowing when the audience is ready for the explosion.

Dialogue, now that’s a potent concoction for regulating pace. Crisp, sharp dialogue keeps the pages turning like a wind-up toy. It’s the rapid-fire exchange of a detective grilling a suspect, the slow, dripping faucet of a confession. The rhythm of conversation is a mystery writer’s metronome.

But pacing isn’t just about speed; it’s about progression. A story must escalate, the stakes rising like dough in a baker’s kitchen until it’s ready to burst out of the oven. Subplots and red herrings are the ingredients adding complexity to the mix. But mind the kitchen; too many cooks and the broth is spoiled. Each subplot must serve the main course, enhancing the flavor without overpowering it.

Set the scene, but don’t let the paint dry. Descriptions are the spice of a scene, but pour too much and the dish is ruined. A smidge of detail here, a dash there, and the reader’s got enough to fire up the imagination without bogging down the action.

Now, sprinkle in some twists. A good twist is like finding a jalapeno in a chocolate chip cookie—unexpected but delightfully jarring. A mystery without a twist is a flat tire on the road to revelation. But the trick is making it fit; a twist that doesn’t tie back to the yarn spun is like a punchline without a joke.

And don’t forget the endgame. The climax is the siren’s call to every reader who’s been dutifully following the breadcrumbs. It’s the crescendo, the final act in the symphony. The trick is to keep the tension tighter than a drum until the final reveal. Then, when the time is right, let it snap with a reveal that leaves the reader breathless but satisfied, like a good cigar after a fine meal.

A mystery, however, isn’t just about the setup and the payoff; it’s about the journey. The road must be fraught with enough peril to keep the reader clinging to the map. The resolution of one enigma should lead to another, like a chain of dominos, each one tipping the next until the last one falls with a satisfying click.

Remember, the pace of a story is the writer’s conductor’s baton. Slow down to let the reader smell the gunpowder, then speed up when the chase is on. Like a good maestro, know when to let the orchestra linger on a note and when to cut to the chase with a staccato rhythm.

Editing, that’s where the real magic happens. It’s the final polish on the brass knuckles before the fight. After the first draft, take the red pen like a scalpel and cut away the fat. Every word that doesn’t scream suspense, every sentence that doesn’t march the story forward, is dead weight. Trim the fat and the story’s as lean as a greyhound.

Now, lest we forget, mystery writing is a contract between the writer and the reader. The writer’s job is to promise a puzzle and deliver a solution that’s both unexpected and inevitable. The reader’s job is to hang on for the ride, trusting the driver not to crash.

Lastly, break the rules. The greatest mystery writers are the ones who know the dance so well they can improvise. They throw out the rulebook and waltz to their own tune. But before you start breaking rules, remember, even the best jazz musicians had to learn to play the scales first.

So, there it is, the straight dope on balancing suspense and pacing in mystery writing. Like a good gumshoe following a hunch, trust the instincts, but don’t forget the legwork. Now, go out there and write a mystery that’s as twisted as Lombard Street and as irresistible as the call of a siren on a foggy San Francisco night. Keep the readers guessing, keep them thrilled, and above all, keep them reading. The rest, as they say, is just details.

Similar Features